Listing Agent Requests Insurance Claim

[CNewhouse 0]

I just received an email from a listing agent regarding a home I inspected several weeks ago. During the inspection, the handle on the master shower valve felt oddly loose, had little resistance when turned, and fell off in my hand. The listing agent is claiming that there was no issue prior to the inspection, and that I broke the valve by "over turning it". This is absurd. It was clearly installed wrong or defective when I arrived. A plumber came out, said the shower valve must be replaced, and gave a quote of nearly $2,000. They want my insurer to pay this. The buyer terminated and I can't help but feel like this is an attempt to punish me. My question is, how do I proceed? This is my first time in this situation and I'm not sure what the appropriate response is. Do I tell the agent respectfully that I did not cause the damage and will not be filing a claim? Do I contact my insurance carrier and let them resolve this?

Edited Wednesday at 02:13 AM by CNewhouse
Typo

[Jim Katen 138]

I'd explain it to the listing agent exactly as you did to us. I'd decline to pay for it and go about my business. If they're serious, they'll follow up but in my experience, they never do. 

[CNewhouse 0]

Great, I appreciate it Jim.

[Marc 83]

I suspect an underlying issue, such as your expertise being too great for the listing agent's liking, wants to damage you if he can. What Jim said. If ever there was a right time to fight, this is it. If your insurance is InspectorPro, update them. If it's not...I dunno if it's a good idea or not to bring them in.

Edited Wednesday at 10:32 PM by Marc

[CNewhouse 0]

52 minutes ago, Marc said:

If ever there was a right time to fight, this is it.

I told the agent that I am paid, in part, to test the showers in the home and that when I did the handle of the shower valve came off in my hand. I told her I take no responsibility for this defect and that it was certainly there before the inspection. I did not use excessive force to turn the shower on. I respectfully declined to contact my insurance or contribute to any repair costs. She insulted me and told me that my "lack of professionalism has been duly noted". Perhaps she has had others lay down when commanded to?

Edited Wednesday at 11:24 PM by CNewhouse

[Marc 83]

1 hour ago, CNewhouse said:

Perhaps she has had others lay down when commanded to?

Wouldn't surprise me.

Money, and the lust for it, changes people.

[Jim Katen 138]

I doubt that you'll ever hear from her or about her again. That kind of behavior doesn't tend to result in a successful career in the world of real estate. 

[John Kogel 35]

Sometimes damage occurs during an open house, perpetrator is long gone, the seller may not be aware it happened, and the agent only hears one side.

The faucet can probably be repaired by a competent plumber. Sounds like a generic estimate for a full replacement with tile work. 

 

[Jim Baird 36]

If the buyer walked that faucet likely was not the only problem you found.  The listing agent was likely used to the "other" kind of inspector who never causes a deal to go down.

[CNewhouse 0]

22 hours ago, Jim Baird said:

If the buyer walked that faucet likely was not the only problem you found.

It was not. I was actually surprised to hear that they terminated, but I can understand wanting a home to be in great shape for the price they were asking. Our area has low inventory, extreme competition and inflated home prices to match.