Jump to content

rpm24

Members
  • Posts

    4
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by rpm24

  1. I know what you mean--I just got back to town after testifying for the defense in an asbestos case. Before 2006, 90% of all asbestos claimants were unimpaired (i.e. not sick). That's what the first and last chapters of my asbestos book are about. More than 80 companies have been driven into bankruptcy, costing at least a hundred thousand jobs.
  2. I'm not arguing that rock wool is dangerous. I'm pointing out that the literature suggests that historically, some rock and mineral wools contained asbestos. I'm an historian of technology, not a building inspector. You will find, however, that the historical producers (not the current ones) of rock and mineral wools are now in bankruptcy and are paying what small amounts they still possess to plaintiffs and their attorneys. If you're interested in my views, you can take a look at my Asbestos & Fire (Johns Hopkins University Press): id="left"> http://www.amazon.com/Asbestos-Fire-Tec ... 0813535751 I note that the website http://www.mesotheliomaweb.org/navyasbe ... lsatoc.htm (not, perhaps, the most objective of sources) is entirely convinced that historically, rock wool and mineral wool were ACMs.
  3. Cox was in the U.S. Navy, so he may be talking only about mineral wool marine insulation. Here is what he said in 1937: p.476 "The rock wool type [of insulation] is composed of nodulated rock wool fibers, clay, and asbestos fibers. This type generally can be easily applied and will adhere to any clean, unheated or heated surface." The 1948 J-M article suggests, but does not state, that there was at least some asbestos in the manufacture of rock wool used in homes. There was a JM mineral wool plant in Asbestos, Quebec that used local stone as stock (on this point, see also Goudge, M. F. "Rock wool." 623-34. Montreal, Canada: Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 1936). p.76 "The other type of rock wool manufactured at Toronto is the batt, used for insulating new homes while they are under construction. By the advanced manufacturing process used at Toronto, long, fine fibres of rock wool are felted into light, resilient batts, uniform in insulating efficiency." The 1974 Winer article abstract says that "A mineral wool of good quality was prepared from a 70:30 mixture of chrysotile asbestos tailings and a local sand from the Eastern Townships of Quebec. A nickeliferous by-product (5% nickel) was recovered, which could be credited to process costs. A preliminary market study and capital costing of the process indicate a viable operation, returning over 20 per cent on investment before taxes." Another source on this issue is Thornbury, William D. "Mineral wool industry of the United States." Economic Geography 14, no. 4 (1938): p.404 "Other forms in which mineral wool is produced are: rock wool cement (mixed with asbestos or clay); pads; panels; plaster; brick; felt; cork board; and, acoustic blankets, pads, and panels." Hausdok, as to your Seattlites, take a look at http://www.resasb.org/. Mineral, rock and slag wool producers have been put into bankruptcy by asbestos litigation. rpm
  4. For the asbestos content of rock and mineral wools, see the following sources: Cox, D. L. "Heat Insulation." Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers. Transactions 44 (1937): 476. "New J-M rock wool plant will help meet Canadian demand for insulation materials." Engineering and Contract Record 61, no. 7 (1948): 7476. Winer, A. "Mineral wool insulation from asbestos tailings." Canadian Mining & Metallurgical Bulletin 67 (1974): 97-104.
×
×
  • Create New...