I can't claim to have any personal experience with unions, but I fully admit that when they came upon the scene over a century ago they were desperately needed. However, to the detriment of the American economy as a whole, I think it became a case of the tail wagging the dog. Just look at the Detroit auto industry as an example. As a homebuilder for 25 years in a non-union state, I have to say that the best brick mason I ever had was an Australian gentleman. No contest whatsoever. He came to Arkansas after having worked for a union in another state. He quickly became very frustrated with the union system, knowing that he could do better on his own. As he related the situation to me, the unions had a productivity quota that you didn't dare exceed. Nor did you grab so much as a single concrete block yourself--you had to let the unskilled labor do that for you. Even if it slowed you down to do so. As an extremely talented mason, he had often laid his quota of block or brick by shortly after lunch. He was expected to sit on his hands for the rest of the afternoon. It didn't take him too long to figure out he could make more money working for himself in a right to work state. This guy did undeniably beautiful work. Head joints all perfectly aligned, bed joints of consistent thickness, and absolutely plumb corners. AND he knew how to slope a window sill properly! He kept TWO laborers hopping while working solo. Most crews here work on the opposite ratio. I can't tell you how much I hated to see him go back home.