I've only had Garmin. Rarely disappointed. Now, I've got the Nuvi from Costco. $149.00 My only beef: the Nuvi's dashboard/windshield mounting cradle does NOT have a live DC connection. The DC connector plugs in to the back of the Nuvi itself. In my older Garmin, the DC cable plugged into the cradle. This made it easy because you merely had to dock the GPS and it would automatically be powered and charged. With the Nuvi, you have to cradle it, then plug the DC cord in. Or, as I use it, just run it on the battery 'til it dies and then plug it to let it charge overnight. P.S. GPS has been some of the best money I've ever spent. We use it frequently when out of town to navigate our way to stores, gas stations, restaurants, etc. in strange lands.