You're never going to have more than a mediocre attic with batt insulation. Blown-in cellulose is a better choice, and once they are there, it can easily to be installed to R-60 at minimal extra cost, with substantial savings down the road (since you had the house built, I assume you plan to stay there and can gain the benefit of extra insulation over the years, especially if energy prices increase). I would remove the batts, sell them on craigslist, do all the air-sealing you can around pipes, wires, etc., figure out a way to deal with the can lights (do some internet reading on this), figure out how to deal with ductwork if any, get the attic access weatherstripped and insulated. This is a weatherization /retrofit / home performance project, and there is a lot of internet reading available on it. Here's one place to start: http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/ ... report.pdf and here's another http://oikos.com/library/airsealing/checklist.html